Databases and different data varieties and structures: Relational or SQL, NoSQL, Graph.

 

Given the wide variety of data sources, data processes and use cases around data, including ‘Big Data’ it is necessary to understand data types and relevant databases to support those datatypes.  Each data type may have a unique flow to how that data is used and analysed.  An example of this would be using a Document NoSQL database to aggregate and report on Log data (systems, operations) within a cloud platform. 

 

Relational databases

The simplest ‘data model’ is that of a ‘Flat File’.  Flat-file storage will not be a valid data model for most firms.  But using a process known as ‘normalisation’ we can turn the Flat File into a relational database.  Normalisation is a set of rules that work together to reduce redundancy, increase reliability, and improve the consistency of data storage.

TableDescription automatically generated

A relational database is built to store structured data so it can be collected, updated, and queried easily. Relational databases rely on a series of structures, called tables, to hold the collected data. These tables are navigated using the structured query language, or SQL.

 

Logically, relational database tables group data based on a person, place, thing, or event related to that data. These groupings are referred to as entities. Each entity is stored as a table.

 

A column, known as a field, is used to describe one attribute of the entity. A row, known as a record, in the table represents a single instance of an entity.

DiagramDescription automatically generated with medium confidence

Think of a spreadsheet, where each row has a cell for each column. Each cell can contain a value. Rules within the schema define if the attribute is required or optional.

 

DiagramDescription automatically generated

 

Relationships are created by first ensuring that every row in a table is unique. This is done by creating a primary key. This primary key value can then be used to create relationships between tables. A foreign key is a field that uses the values from a primary key in another table to define a record in the current table. This act is what builds the relationship. Some database engines can enforce this relationship to ensure that only values from the primary key can be used in the foreign key.

 

Strengths

 

Weaknesses

 

The image below provides an example of how you can take flat-file data and turn it into a relational data structure.  A Flat File spreadsheet may contain in one xls tab, the Customer Information, the Product, and Order information.  You can take the different areas and create tables with unique Primary and Secondary Keys which can be used to query the data; namely, Customer, Product and Order tables.

 

Graphical user interface, tableDescription automatically generated

 

Structured Data

Structured data is classified as data that is stored in a database or database management system (DBMS). A database is a structured set of data held in a computer—one that is accessible in various ways. A DBMS provides structure to the data, the ability to maintain the data throughout its lifecycle, and the ability to manage interactions with other processes and systems. Different database management systems manage data organization in different ways to achieve specific goals, such as complex analysis, rapid relationship navigation, or session state retrieval.

 

Relational Systems: OLTP, OLAP

There are two main ways—known as information systems—of organizing data within a relational database. The data can be organized to focus on the storage of transactions or the process of analysing transactions.

 

Transactional databases are called online transaction processing (OLTP) databases. The data gathered by OLTP databases is often fed into another type of database that focuses on analysing the transactional data. Online analytical processing (OLAP) databases gather data from OLTP systems for the purpose of organizing it for analytical operations.

 

Relational database pros and cons

The primary benefit of a relational database using SQL is that it is proven technology that is widely adopted and understood. There is less risk involved with a relational database, especially due to ACID compliance and a large community of experts in the field. There is an expectation of very good transactional latency, especially on appropriately sized hardware, and relational databases are considered outstanding for OLTP for relatively small data sets.

 

There are scalability concerns with a relational database. As data sets grow, the only way to maintain performance is to increase the hardware capacities of the servers that run the application. Another key issue is the fixed schema of relational databases. It is difficult to make non-disruptive changes to the underlying database architectures, which can affect development times for new functionality.

 

Preparing relational data for data processing

When working with a relational database, you must pay attention to how the data will be used within the data analysis solution. It is very common to perform multiple types of analytics on the same data. OLTP data may need to be transformed into a denormalized form and placed into a data warehouse or data mart. OLAP data may not require any transformation. There may even be opportunities to transform data into staging databases that can be used as a data source for other analytic processes.

 

Semi structured and unstructured data are often stored in non-relational database systems, sometimes called NoSQL databases. This term can cause a bit of confusion. It is important to remember that SQL is a way of querying data. It implies precise structure. Non-relational or NoSQL does not mean the data stored cannot be queried using SQL. A better way to think of it is not only SQL.

 

Document stores are a type of non-relational database that store semi structured and unstructured data in the form of files. These files range in form but include JSON, BSON, and XML. The files can be navigated using numerous languages including Python and Node.js.

 

Logically, files contain data stored as a series of elements. Each element is an instance of a person, place, thing, or event. For instance, the document store may hold a series of log files from a set of servers. These log files can each contain the specifics for that system without concern for what the log files in other systems contain.

 

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

 

Key-value stores

Key-value databases are a type of non-relational database that store unstructured data in the form of key-value pairs.

 

Logically, data is stored in a single table. Within the table, the values are associated with a specific key. The values are stored in the form of blob objects and do not require a predefined schema. The values can be of nearly any type.

 

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

 

What is a blob?  A blob is a binary large object namely, sounds and multimedia files. Blob’s have a comparatively larger size than most data types and can contain up to gigabytes of data.

 

A relational database on the other hand will store data in the form of a table which contains rows, with each row representing for example, a single product that can be sold. Each column stores an attribute of that product: The Product ID, Product Name, Supplier, Price, and Unit. Note that both products have an entry for every attribute.  A column is also called a field.  A row is called a record.

 

Graphical user interface, textDescription automatically generated

 

Imagine that now the needs of the business have changed. You need to add a new column to track each product's rating. Not all products have a rating yet, so you need to allow the column to accept NULL values.

 

To add a new column to the table, you must:

  1. Execute a SQL command to add the column.
  2. The table now contains an empty column.
  3. Populate the new column with a value for each existing record.

 

When the same requirement is placed on data in a non-relational database, the remedy is quite different. You simply add the data for that record.  With a non-relational database, each record can have its own set of attributes. This flexibility is one of the greatest benefits of non-relational databases.

 

Text, letterDescription automatically generated

 

Graph databases are purpose-built to store any type of data: structured, semi-structured, or unstructured. The purpose for organization in a graph database is to navigate relationships. Data within the database is queried using specific languages associated with the software tool you have implemented.

 

Logically, data is stored as a node, and edges store information on the relationships between nodes. An edge always has a start node, end node, type, and direction, and an edge can describe parent-child relationships, actions, ownership, and the like. There is no limit to the number and kind of relationships a node can have.

 

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

 

Non-relational database pros and cons

Non-relational databases have the primary benefit of going beyond the limitations of relational databases, especially through dynamic schemas, which give DBAs the ability to update schemas on the fly. This leads to faster development cycles and less downtime. Also, because non-relational databases can be deployed on massively distributed commodity servers, these databases have an advantage in scaling and can handle much larger data sets.

 

The massive distribution does have a downside, in the form of “eventual consistency,” which means that data is not instantaneously updated with every change and instead catches up as a background task. Although this is acceptable under many circumstances, it does make ACID compliance difficult to achieve. Note that DynamoDB in AWS which is a popular NoSQL product does support ACID compliance.

 

Another drawback is that non-relational databases do not perform as well as relational databases in applications that require extremely low transactional latency. Finally, although non-relational platforms are constantly developing and growing, there isn’t nearly the same maturity as relational technologies or the same amount of field expertise.

 

Comparing relational and non-relational databases

There are many factors that can help you determine which database type is best for a new project or program you are developing. Below are the key characteristics of all three database types we have covered.

 

Characteristic

Relational

Non-relational

Graph

Representation

Multiple tables, each containing columns and rows

Collection of documents
Single table with keys and values

Collections of nodes and relationships

Data design

Normalized relational or dimensional data warehouse.

Denormalized document, wide column or key value

Denormalized entity relationship

Optimized

Optimized for storage

Optimized for compute

Optimized for relationships

Query style

Language: SQL

Language: many
Uses object querying

Language: many
Uses object querying

Scaling

Scale vertically

Scale horizontally

Hybrid

Implementation

OLTP business systems, OLAP data warehouse

OLTP web/mobile apps

OLTP web/mobile app

 

Examples:

 

A multi-dimensional data warehouse is best suited for a relational database.

 

Log files are generally produced in the form of XML or JSON files, which are very well suited for storage in a document database.

 

Data collected from online gaming websites is often very rapid in generation and temporary in nature. This data is well suited for a key-value database.

 

Transactional data from a social subscription service could be stored in a relational database, but due to the social component, it would be better suited to the advantages gained by using a graph database.